FreshRSS

🔒
❌ Acerca de FreshRSS
Hay nuevos artículos disponibles. Pincha para refrescar la página.
AnteayerTus fuentes RSS

Simulation of phased alerting of community first responders for cardiac arrest

by Pieter L. van den Berg, Shane G. Henderson, Hemeng Li, Bridget Dicker, Caroline J. Jagtenberg

Background

Community First Responders (CFRs) are commonly used for out-of-hospital cardiac arrests, and advanced systems send so-called phased alerts: notifications with built-in time delays. The policy that defines these delays affects both response times and volunteer fatigue.

Methods

We compare alert policies by Monte Carlo Simulation, estimating patient survival, coverage, number of alerts and redundant CFR arrivals. In the simulation, acceptance probabilities and response delays are bootstrapped from 29,307 rows of historical data covering all GoodSAM alerts in New Zealand between 1-12-2017 and 30-11-2020. We simulate distances between the patient and CFRs by assuming that CFRs are located uniformly at random in a 1-km circle around the patient, for different CFR densities. Our simulated CFRs travel with a distance-dependent speed that was estimated by linear regression on observed speeds among those responders in the above-mentioned data set that eventually reached the patient.

Results

The alerting policy has a large impact on the four metrics above, and the best choice depends on volunteer density. For each volunteer density, we are able to identify a policy that improves GoodSAM New Zealand’s current policy on all four metrics. For example, when there are 30 volunteers within 1 km from the patient, sending out alerts to 7 volunteers and replacing each volunteer that rejects by a new one, is expected to save 10 additional lives per year compared to the current policy, without increasing volunteer fatigue. Our results also shed light on polices that would improve one metric while worsening another, for example, when there are 10 volunteers within 1 km from the patient, dispatching them all immediately increases our survival estimate by 11% compared to the current policy, with the downside of also increasing the redundant arrivals by 137%.

Conclusions

Monte Carlo simulation can help CFR system managers identify a good policy before implementing it in practice. We recommend balancing survival and volunteer fatigue, aiming to ultimately further improve a CFR system’s effectiveness.

Ectoparasite abundance and pathogen prevalence of the San Clemente Island fox (<i>Urocyon littoralis clementae)</i>

by David A. Green, Jesse M. Maestas, Jessica N. Sanchez, Nathan C. Nieto, Andrew S. Bridges, David K. Garcelon

The San Clemente Island fox (Urocyon littoralis clementae) is classified as a focal species for conservation management by the US Navy. They are considered vulnerable to a variety of vector-borne diseases due to their relatively high population density and low genetic diversity. During the dry (July–November) and wet (December–February) seasons of 2017–2018 we live-trapped 95 foxes and collected ectoparasites to test for the presence of pathogens. We found a significant difference in ectoparasite abundance on foxes between seasons, but no differences associated with sex or age. We found that foxes carried two species of flea (Echidnophaga gallinacea and Orchopeas howardi) and two tick species (Ixodes pacificus and Ixodes jellisoni). No evidence of Borrelia burgdorferi, Anaplasma phagocytophilum, or Borrelia miyamotoi bacteria were found. This paper is the first account of ectoparasite species identification, quantification, and pathogen testing for the San Clemente Island fox subspecies.

Preventing vertical transmission of hepatitis B in sub-Saharan Africa: protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis on vaccination uptake and determinants among pregnant women

Por: Afolabi · I. B. · Phillips · J. C. · El-Chaar · D. · Bainbridge · S. A. · Phillips · K. P.
Background

Effective prevention of maternal-fetal transmission of hepatitis B virus (HBV) in highly endemic settings depends on targeting vaccination efforts to key priority groups, including pregnant women. However, the extent of HBV vaccination and determinants of uptake in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) have not been systematically examined. This systematic review aims to estimate HBV vaccination among pregnant women in SSA and identify the broader factors influencing uptake.

Methods and analysis

This review will follow the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Protocols (PRISMA) guidelines. A comprehensive literature search will be conducted in MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, Scopus, African Journals Online and Google Scholar in November 2025. We will include published observational studies that assess HBV vaccination among pregnant women in SSA countries from database inception to October 2025. A meta-analysis will be conducted using random-effects models to pool estimates of HBV vaccination and multivariable-adjusted ORs for vaccination-associated factors. Statistical heterogeneity will be assessed using the I² statistic.

Ethics and dissemination

Ethical approval is not required as this review will not involve primary data collection. Findings will be published in a peer-reviewed journal, presented at regional and international public health conferences, and, where applicable, shared with policymakers and health authorities in SSA.

PROSPERO registration number

This protocol is registered with the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews, registration number CRD420251120357.

A Concept Analysis of the Dynamics of Risk, Midwifery Agency and the Maternity Early Warning Tool

ABSTRACT

Aim

To examine the concept of midwifery agency when using Maternity Early Warning Tools.

Design

Concept analysis using Rogers' evolutionary method.

Methods

Data were collected from interviews with midwives working in various Australian maternity settings. A subset of the dataset was collected and analysed (2021–2022) to examine how agency functions when midwives use Maternity Early Warning Tools.

Results

Three conceptual attributes fundamental to agency were identified: considered judgement, reasoned clinical decision-making, and collaborative action. These attributes reveal how midwives navigate the interface between structured risk management tools and relational, woman-centred care.

Conclusions

Maternity Early Warning Tools can either limit or enhance professional agency. When used reflexively, they become artefacts that support learning, communication, and sound clinical judgement. Viewing these tools as enablers rather than enforcers sustains midwifery expertise and strengthens interdisciplinary collaboration.

Implications for the Profession and/or Patient

Sustaining midwifery agency protects both professional integrity and the quality of woman-centred care.

Impact

What problem did the study address? How the use of Maternity Early Warning Tools influences midwives' agency.

Rates and waiting times of elective surgeries in Queensland: an aggregated data analysis by Indigenous status, 2013-2022

Por: Mahmoud · I. · Baneshi · M. R. · Zolal · F. · Fan · L. · Bainbridge · R. · Hou · X.-Y.
Objectives

To compare elective surgeries rates and waiting times between Indigenous and non-Indigenous patients in Queensland.

Design

Aggregated annual data analysis from July 2013 to December 2022 on elective surgeries and waiting times.

Setting

Public hospitals across Queensland.

Participants

All patients who had elective surgery in Queensland public hospitals between 2013 and 2022.

Measures

Rates and clinically recommended timeframes for elective surgeries.

Results

Between 2013 and 2022, the overall estimated average rate of elective surgeries for Indigenous patients was 286 per 100 000 population, compared with 221 per 100 000 for non-Indigenous patients. Indigenous patients had higher rates of most elective surgeries except plastic and urological surgeries, where non-Indigenous patients had higher rates. Across all urgency categories, the percentages of elective surgery performed within clinically recommended timeframes were similar between Indigenous and non-Indigenous patients.

Conclusion

Our findings may point to the efficacy of specific policy and service delivery innovations undertaken in Queensland. Due to the limitations of our aggregated data, this inference warrants careful interpretation. More studies with disaggregated data are needed.

Physician beliefs regarding venous thromboembolism prophylaxis at a large multihospital US healthcare system: a cross-sectional survey study

Por: Moss · S. R. · Bhattacharyya · O. · Mittman · B. G. · Gunaratne · T. · Campoamor · N. B. · Bridges · J. F. · Rothberg · M. B.
Background

Venous thromboembolism (VTE) contributes to hospitalisation-associated morbidity. Although guidelines recommend limiting VTE prophylaxis to high-risk patients, some physicians prescribe it broadly. We compared beliefs of low and high prescribing physicians.

Methods

We surveyed hospitalists and medical residents who had the opportunity to prescribe prophylaxis ≥50 times. Best-worst scaling was used to assess their beliefs. Using a balanced incomplete block design, we created seven choice tasks with seven statements regarding prophylaxis beliefs each presented four times. For each task, physicians selected the statement that most and least reflected their beliefs. We used a count method to calculate best-worst scores and a conditional logistic regression choice model to compare low and high prescribers.

Results

Of 434 invitees, 172 (40%) completed all survey questions between June and November 2023. Low (n=86, ≤62.5% prescribing rate) and high (n=86, >62.5 prescribing rate) prescribers endorsed similar beliefs with differing levels of agreement. All felt confident to prescribe prophylaxis appropriately (low: +1.13, high: +1.10, p=0.81). High prescribers expressed more concern about VTE without prophylaxis (+1.02 vs +0.65, p=0.002). Low prescribers disagreed more that prophylaxis had no downside (–1.03 vs –0.73, p=0.01). High prescribers worried less about prophylaxis risks (–0.49 vs –0.22, p=0.01), and overuse (–0.61 vs –0.34, p=0.02).

Conclusions

Compared with low prescribers, high prescribers were more concerned about VTE without prophylaxis and less about harms. These differences in beliefs may underlie physician behaviour and could be targets for interventions to reduce inappropriate prophylaxis.

Patient satisfaction with infection prevention and control interventions in acute hospitals: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Por: Skally · M. · Kearney · A. · Strawbridge · J. · Heritage · J. · Cox · C. · Bennett · K. E. · Humpreys · H. · Fitzpatrick · F.
Introduction

Infection prevention and control (IPC) interventions are multifactorial and are used to prevent healthcare-associated infections in healthcare facilities. However, patient views and enabling patient and public involvement (PPI) in their development has been minimal.

Objectives

This systematic review aims to identify peer-reviewed publications reporting patient satisfaction outcomes in the context of IPC interventions, to document the methods used to assess patient satisfaction and to conduct a meta-analysis on reported satisfaction outcomes.

Design

Systematic review and meta-analysis following the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology and the PRISMA statement, with oversight from a steering group including PPI partners. Studies in peer-reviewed journals were included based on eligibility criteria.

Data sources

MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and PsycINFO were searched in June 2024.

Eligibility criteria

Included studies investigated satisfaction among hospitalised patients in acute care settings following IPC measures, including isolation, cohorting, screening, hand hygiene, antimicrobial stewardship, patient flagging, education, personal protective equipment use, visiting restrictions and treatment delays

Data extraction and synthesis

Titles and abstracts were screened independently by two reviewers; disagreements were resolved by a third. Study quality was assessed using the JBI manual for evidence synthesis. A meta-analysis was conducted where four or more studies used comparable designs and methods within the same areas of IPC, with heterogeneity evaluated using Cochran’s Q statistic and I2 and pooled estimates calculated with 95% CIs using the Wilson (score) method.

Results

Twenty-nine studies were identified. Among IPC measures, isolation precautions were the most commonly reported intervention (11 studies, 38%). The Likert scale was the predominant assessment method (13 studies, 45%). Patient satisfaction with IPC interventions ranged from 58.3% to 97.2%. Meta-analysis of four studies using the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems survey showed substantial heterogeneity (I2, 55%, p=0.08) and a pooled patient satisfaction level of 69% (95% CI 63.6% to 74.4%) for isolation precautions.

Conclusion

Sixty-nine percent of isolated patients reported satisfaction with their care. Patient satisfaction with IPC interventions varies widely, highlighting limitations in current measurement approaches. Strengthening PPI in the design and evaluation of satisfaction measures is essential to capture meaningful data and improvements in IPC programmes.

PROSPERO registration number

IS 2024 CRD42024558385.

Protocol for a modified Delphi study of ethical oversight of data science health research (DSHR)

Introduction

The use of data science for health research produces complex ethical, legal and social challenges that traditional ethical oversight mechanisms struggle to address. In Nigeria, the current ethical guidelines were not designed for these challenges which include pervasive data environments, consent for secondary data use, algorithmic decision-making and bias, privacy risks, involvement of commercial entities, data colonisation, inequitable benefit-sharing and commercial data holdings. To address these gaps, we developed a draft guideline incorporating principles like trust, veracity, global justice and alternative ethical approval mechanisms. Here, we describe the protocol for a study aimed at validating the guideline through stakeholder consensus on the content, feasibility and acceptability of this subcode for national implementation.

Methods and analysis

We describe the use of a modified e-Delphi approach to iteratively synthesize expert opinions about ethical oversight for data science health research (DSHR) led by a multidisciplinary working group from the Bridging Gaps in the ELSI of Data Science Health Research in Nigeria (BridgELSI) team. We will invite 65 experts, including health researchers, ethics committee members, data scientists, health policymakers, funders and key opinion leaders in Nigeria to participate. Participants will rate 13 core principles, including global justice, algorithmic bias, data governance and related governance provisions on importance, desirability for inclusion in national guidelines, feasibility and confidence in implementation, using 5-point Likert scales, with optional free-text comments. We will summarise responses using descriptive statistics, assess consensus and polarity using pre-specified thresholds for the mean and IQR, and iteratively refine statements between rounds using qualitative content analysis of comments.

Ethics and dissemination

Ethical approval was obtained from the Nigerian National Health Research Ethics Committee and the University of Maryland IRB, and participants will provide informed consent. Results will be shared with the expert panel and national regulators and disseminated via publications and conferences.

Mixed-methods non-randomised single-arm feasibility study assessing delivery of a remote vocational rehabilitation intervention for patients with serious injury: the ROWTATE study

Por: Kellezi · B. · Holmes · J. · Kettlewell · J. · Lindley · R. · Radford · K. · Patel · P. · Bridger · K. · Lannin · N. A. · Andrews · I. · Blackburn · L. · Brooks · A. · das Nair · R. · Fallon · S. · Farrin · A. · Hoffman · K. · Jones · T. · Morriss · R. · Timmons · S. · Kendrick · D.
Objectives

This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility of delivering a vocational rehabilitation intervention (Return to Work After Trauma—ROWTATE), remotely to individuals recovering from traumatic injuries. The primary objectives were to assess therapists’ training and competence, adapt the intervention and training for remote delivery and assess the feasibility and fidelity of remote delivery to inform a definitive randomised controlled trial.

Design

A mixed-methods feasibility study incorporating (1) telerehabilitation qualitative literature review, (2) qualitative interviews preintervention and postintervention with therapists and patients, (3) a team objective structured clinical examination to assess competency, (4) usefulness of training, attitudes towards (15-item Evidence-Based Practice Attitude Scale) and confidence in (4-item Evidence Based Practice Confidence Scale) evidence-based practice, intervention delivery confidence (8-bespoke questions) and intervention behaviour determinants (51-items Theoretical Domains Framework) and (5) single-arm intervention delivery feasibility study.

Setting

The study was conducted in two UK Major Trauma Centres. The intervention and training were adapted for remote delivery due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Participants

Therapists: Seven occupational therapists (OTs) and clinical psychologists (CPs) were trained, and six participated in competency assessment. Seven OTs and CPs participated in preintervention interviews and surveys; six completed post-intervention interviews and four completed post-training surveys. Patients: 10 patients were enrolled in the single-arm feasibility study and 4 of these participated in postintervention qualitative interviews. Inclusion criteria included therapists involved in vocational rehabilitation delivery and patients admitted to major trauma centres. Exclusion criteria included participation in other vocational rehabilitation trials or those who had returned to work or education for at least 80% of preinjury hours. Intervention: The ROWTATE vocational rehabilitation intervention was delivered remotely by trained OTs and CPs. Training included competency assessments, mentoring and adaptation for telerehabilitation. The intervention was delivered over multiple sessions, with content tailored to individual patient needs.

Results

Therapists found the training useful, reported positive attitudes (Evidence-Based Practice Attitude Scale mean=2.9 (SD 0.9)) and high levels of confidence in delivering evidence-based practice (range 75%–100%) and the ROWTATE intervention (range 80%–100%). Intervention barriers identified pretraining became facilitators post-training. Half the therapists needed additional support post-training through mentoring or additional training. The intervention and training were successfully adapted for remote delivery. High levels of fidelity (intervention components delivered: OTs=84.5%, CPs=92.9%) and session attendance rates were found (median: OT=97%, CP=100%). Virtually all sessions were delivered remotely (OT=98%, CP=100%). The intervention was acceptable to patients and therapists; both considered face-to-face delivery where necessary was important.

Conclusions

The ROWTATE intervention was delivered remotely with high fidelity and attendance and was acceptable to patients and therapists. Definitive trial key changes include modifying therapist training, competency assessment, face-to-face intervention delivery where necessary and addressing lower fidelity intervention components.

Trial registration number

ISRCTN74668529.

Enablers and barriers of e-learning utilising smart technologies in type 2 diabetes care for clinicians: a systematic review

Por: Alanazi · M. M. · Fellas · A. · Bridge · P. · Acharya · S. · Santos · D. · Sculley · D. · Girones · X. · Coda · A.
Objectives

Continuous Glucose Monitoring (CGM) supports Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) management, but healthcare professionals (HCPs) often face challenges interpreting data. E-learning platforms can enhance knowledge, skills and confidence. This systematic review identified enablers and barriers to e-learning for CGM interpretation.

Design

Systematic review conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines.

Data sources

PubMed, Ovid MEDLINE, Ovid Embase, Cochrane Library, Scopus, Web of Science and CINAHL were searched on 7 February 2024.

Eligibility criteria for selecting studies

Studies of HCPs using e-learning for T2D management were included, both comparative and non-comparative. Outcomes included enablers and barriers. Eligible designs were randomised, quasi-experimental, controlled before-and-after and observational studies. No restrictions on setting or language; conference abstracts included if full text was available

Data extraction and synthesis

Two reviewers independently screened and extracted data using a predefined form; disagreements were resolved by a third reviewer. Thematic analysis identified key enablers and barriers. Methodological quality was assessed using the Downs and Black checklist, and findings were synthesised narratively.

Results

Four studies met inclusion criteria, including 6790 participants (physicians, nurses, midwives and medical residents). E-learning improved knowledge and skills. Emami et al reported increased knowledge of T2D diagnosis and treatment (p=0.001), while Okuroğlu and Alpar found improvements in diabetes care knowledge and skills (pet al noted enhanced self-reported performance (p=0.03) and 84% satisfaction. Enablers included flexibility and accessibility, while barriers involved time constraints, resistance to change and methodological limitations (self-selection bias, lack of blinding). Study quality ranged from fair (three studies) to poor (one study).

Conclusion

Based on current evidence, it is unclear if e-learning can significantly enhance HCPs’ knowledge, skills and confidence in T2D management. Barriers such as time constraints and resistance to change remain, and the limited number and quality of studies restrict the generalisability of these findings. E-learning may offer potential benefits, but further robust randomised controlled trials are needed to evaluate long-term outcomes and strategies to overcome these challenges.

PROSPERO registration number

CRD42023455156.

A longitudinal, population-based, record-linked natural experiment on the effects of extreme heat events on mental health in urban communities: a study protocol

Por: Chukwusa · E. · Vivaldi · G. · Baecker · L. · Bowerman · E. · Bridge · N. · Davidson · N. · de la Cruz · A. · Gasparrini · A. · Gibbons · J. · Guerry · A. · Hammoud · R. · Li · Y. · Lu · Y. · Mandle · L. · Osborn · D. · Rydstrom · A. · Smythe · M. · Stewart · R. · Tognin · S. · White · M. · Ya
Introduction

Studies suggest that extreme heat events can have negative effects on mental health. However, characterisation of these effects in urban communities remains limited, and few studies have investigated the potential modifying effects of demographic, clinical and environmental characteristics. The aim of this study is to address this knowledge gap and quantify the impacts of extreme heat on mental health, health service use and mental well-being in vulnerable urban populations.

Methods and analysis

In this multidisciplinary project, we will assess mental health outcomes in different populations by bringing together two distinct datasets: electronic health record (EHR) data on mental health service users and data from general public participants of Urban Mind, a citizen science project. We will use EHRs from the South London and Maudsley NHS Foundation Trust (SLaM) and the North London NHS Foundation Trust (NLFT), from six boroughs which collectively cover more than 1.8 million residents in Greater London, to capture mental health service use and mortality among people with existing diagnoses of mental illness across 2008–2023. We will use smartphone-based ecological momentary assessment data from Urban Mind to measure mental well-being in the general population (2018–2023). These datasets will be linked to high-resolution spatiotemporal data on temperature, fine and coarse particulate matter (PM2.5, PM10), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and density of large mature tree canopy. We will employ novel quasi-experimental designs, including case time series and case-crossover analysis, to examine the impact of extreme heat on mental health and explore effect modification by sociodemographic, clinical and environmental factors, including air pollution and types of green space coverage. We will also develop a microsimulation model combined with the InVEST urban cooling model to assess and forecast the mental health and social care impacts of extreme heat events and the mitigation of these impacts by different green space coverage and pollution-reduction policies. With a core team composed of researchers, community organisations, industry partners and specialist policy experts, this project will consider lived experience, benefit from broad stakeholder engagement and address gaps in policy and practice.

Ethics and dissemination

Each component of this project has been approved by the relevant ethics committee (ref RESCM-22/23-6905 for Urban Mind, LRS/DP-23/24-41409 for the co-development of a screening tool, 23/SC/0257 for the SLaM EHRs, and 24/EE/0178 for the NLFT EHRs). Our dissemination plan includes peer-reviewed scientific articles, policy briefs, a practical guide on fostering ecological and human resilience at the neighbourhood level, and a technical guide for planting and improving the growing conditions of large canopy trees.

Mental Health Nurses' Perception of Clinical Supervision Implementation Mapped Against a Program Logic: A Survey Study

ABSTRACT

Clinical supervision is claimed to benefit nurses' wellbeing, professional development and practice. However, evaluations highlight implementation challenges, and universal uptake among nurses is uncommon, which limits benefits and the quality of evaluations. This paper reports outcomes of a government policy initiative to implement clinical supervision in Victoria, Australia, with survey data generated through a program logic evaluation.

Aim

To explore nurses' perceptions of the implementation of clinical supervision, specifically addressing training adequacy, participation rates, organisational support, cultural growth and relational capacity development.

Design

A cross-sectional survey of nursing supervisees was conducted within a program of research investigating the governmental implementation of clinical supervision.

Method

A survey of 366 participating nurses across four separate organisations addressed the following outcome evaluation questions, arising from program logic objectives: Are nurses currently engaged in clinical supervision? What is the relationship between clinical supervision implementation and: (1) nurses' preparation for clinical supervision, (2) their experience of the organisation valuing clinical supervision and (3) valuing nurses' own wellbeing and (4) nurses' perception of their own growth in relational practice?

Results

The findings affirm the clinical supervision implementation program by showing positive associations for the intended outcomes. Nurses reported: they had sufficient training in clinical supervision; their workplaces were experienced as supportive of clinical supervision and nurturing of the participants; and they had growth in relational ability. Each positive finding was significantly stronger for the sub-sample (65%) of study participants who were currently engaged in clinical supervision compared to those who were not.

Conclusion

The study foregrounds the contribution of program logic, within a multifaceted initiative and including a strong authorising environment, to the implementation of clinical supervision.

Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care

Implementation of clinical supervision across services can be enabled by values-congruent strategies, including high-level authorising, stakeholder objective setting, training and coalition of change agents.

Impact

This paper addresses the gap between numerous local intervention studies of clinical supervision for nurses and the lack of empirical studies informing system-wide implementation approaches. Our survey investigating implementation outcomes shows that nurses experience of the implementation was aligned to program objectives: participating nurses considered themselves effectively trained for clinical supervision and supported by the organisation, with a positive impact on their own practice. This study can assist organisations in considering large-scale implementation of clinical supervision, with a future focus on levels of uptake and impact on practice.

Reporting Method

We have adhered to relevant EQUATOR guidelines for survey method (i.e., the CROSS checklist).

Patient or Public Contribution

Mental Health Consumer and Carer Advisors within the Office of the Chief Mental Health Nurse, Department of Health and Human Services, Victoria, contributed to the establishment of the research evaluation objectives and related survey items. They contributed perspectives via initial project design meetings and further feedback informing the final version of the program logic.

Factors that influence the clinical supervision implementation for nurses: A scoping review

Abstract

Aims

The aim of this review is to identify and map the evidence available on the factors that influence the implementation of clinical supervision for nurses.

Design

The scoping review was conducted and reported following the JBI methodology for scoping reviews.

Data Sources

Searches were conducted on MEDLINE, PsycINFO, and CINAHL databases on 28 March 2023.

Review Methods

A total of 1398 studies were imported into Covidence for screening. Researchers screened the papers according to the inclusion criteria. Empirical studies in English focusing on the implementation of clinical supervision for nurses were included, without year restrictions. Data from 16 studies were extracted and organized according to the constructs within the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) domains: intervention characteristics, outer setting, inner setting, characteristics of individuals, and process.

Results

When compared with the CFIR constructs, it was found that the influence of the outer setting on implementation was less explored in the literature. Most of the reviewed data highlighted recurring factors, particularly logistical challenges of nursing work such as shift work and lack of control over work time. Organizational culture and managerial support were also identified as significant factors in the implementation. Another significant challenge in implementation was the variety in clinical supervision's design, purpose, and application, despite sharing the same label, leading to questions about whether studies are implementing the same practice.

Conclusion

Policy documents should clearly define both the design and purpose of clinical supervision, beyond just its conceptual definition. Greater emphasis on equitable implementation of clinical supervision is necessary to prevent perpetuating existing inequalities. We conclude that implementation of such complex interventions is not linear, and the implementation strategies need to align with expected implementation challenges.

Impact

The advantage of using the implementation framework lies not only in observing what exists as a form of evidence but also in identifying what is underdeveloped. Healthcare services and policy developers can utilize our review to recognize and address potential challenges in introducing, modifying, scaling up, or sustaining their clinical supervision implementation.

Patient or Public Contribution

No patient or public contribution.

"Should be a dynamic tool": Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander primary health care service staff perspectives on an effective patient reported experience measure (PREM) in Australia - a qualitative study

Por: Chakraborty · A. · Walke · E. · Laycock · A. F. · Piccoli · T. · Matthews · V. · Walpole · R. · Bailie · R. · Burgess · P. · Langham · E. · Larkins · S. · Bainbridge · R. · Brown · B. · Silver · B. · Swaminathan · G. · Smorgon · S. · Turner · N. · Passey · M.
Objectives

The Validating Outcomes by Including Consumer Experience (VOICE) project is developing patient reported experience measure (PREM) tools to collect consumer feedback for Indigenous primary healthcare (IPHC) services’ accreditation and quality improvement processes. This study aimed to explore the views of health service staff about: (1) optimising the feasibility of collection, analysis and interpretation of findings; and (2) resourcing requirements for implementation of the PREM.

Design

A participatory action research qualitative study design, guided by an Indigenous advisory group. Our team of Indigenous and non-Indigenous researchers conducted semistructured focus groups and individual interviews with IPHC staff. Focus groups and interviews were recorded, transcribed and thematically analysed. Multiple sense-making meetings were conducted with the Indigenous advisory group.

Setting

Eight partner IPHC services across four Australian states and territories.

Participants

All staff were eligible and invited to participate in the study via purposive and snowball sampling. Administrative staff (eg, receptionist, programme facilitator), clinicians/practitioners (eg, general practitioner, nurse, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health workers and practitioners) and service managers (eg, CEO, practice manager) from partner health services participated.

Results

63 staff participated; 44 attended across 13 focus groups, with the remainder participating in individual interviews. The majority of participants were between 35 years and 55 years old (52%), female (66%) and working in frontline IPHC service delivery roles (56%). Equal numbers identified as Indigenous (50%) and non-Indigenous (50%). Many had worked in the Indigenous health and well-being sector for over 10 years (40%). ‘Culturally safe care’ and ‘accountability’ were identified as primary themes and key reasons for gathering consumer feedback. Subthemes identified were ‘Relationships’, ‘trust and respect’, ‘communication about consumer feedback’, ‘timing and frequency of requesting consumer feedback’, ‘health service systems’, ‘health service and staff capacity’, ‘staff skills’ and ‘structure and administration of the PREM’. All themes and subthemes need to be considered for the successful design and implementation of PREMs in IPHC settings.

Conclusion

Many of the issues identified are not currently considered in the process of collecting PREM data for accreditation yet, if addressed, would likely improve the quality and relevance of data collected. The findings from this study will inform the co-design and validation of Indigenous-specific PREM tools to collect consumer feedback. Critically, service and community input will ensure the PREM tools meet service needs for continuous quality improvement and accreditation and reflect the priorities and values of Indigenous peoples.

Youth Med.Info: a case study in co-design of mental health medicines-information resources for children, young people and their parents/guardians

Por: Hynes-Ryan · C. · Kelleher · I. · Kathryn · S. · Beaudelot · C. · Carolan · A. · Columb · D. · Donnelly · S. · Gamage · N. · Hill · N. · Migone · M. · McWilliams · S. · Morning · J. · ODonoghue · B. · Solan · I. · Strawbridge · J. · Hayden · J. C. · Keating · D.
Objectives

To address the lack of accurate and accessible mental health medicines-information resources for children, young people and their parents/guardians using design thinking to co-design free-to-use, video resources tailored to this audience.

Design

A multiphase qualitative case study using the Double Diamond model of Design Thinking: Discover, Define, Develop and Deliver. This included iterative prototyping, thematic analysis and public and patient involvement throughout.

Setting

Dublin, Ireland with online distribution of the final resources internationally through a free, open-access platform.

Participants

A multidisciplinary co-design team including two specialist mental health pharmacists, two academic pharmacists, five consultant psychiatrists, a psychiatric nurse, a youth content specialist, three youth activists and a parent representative.

Results

26 co-designed, medicines-information videos were created, including versions for children (voiced by children), parents/guardians and young people. Videos feature storytelling formats with Bitmoji characters. Feedback from youth and parent collaborators guided design and content. Since launch, www.youthmed.info has had over 25 000 website views and more than 30 000 video views, with engagement from over 91 countries. The resources are also linked on national and international clinical and charity platforms.

Conclusions

Youth Med.Info addresses a gap in accessible, accurate mental health medicines-information by placing users – children, young people, parents/guardians and clinicians—at the centre of its design.

Effects of a drinking motives and readiness to change tailored digital alcohol intervention among online help-seekers: protocol for a randomised controlled trial

Por: Crawford · J. · Collier · E. · Ulfsdotter Gunnarsson · K. · Shorter · G. · McCambridge · J. · Lundgren · O. · Bendtsen · M.
Introduction

Alcohol consumption that damages health remains highly prevalent in Sweden despite macrolevel intervention measures such as availability, restrictions and taxation. As understanding of behaviour change develops, there may be an opportunity to enhance individual level interventions by targeting personal dimensions of behaviour, such as underlying motives for drinking alcohol and readiness to change behaviour. This protocol describes a randomised controlled trial aimed at estimating the effectiveness of an intervention tailored to motives and readiness to change.

Methods and analysis

A three-arm, parallel groups, randomised controlled trial will be used to estimate the effects of a motives and readiness to change tailored intervention. We will use a Bayesian sequential design to decide when to stop recruitment, with target criteria for benefit, harm and futility. Recruitment will be completed via web adverts and social media. Inclusion criteria are being aged 18 or older, having access to a mobile phone and being classified as a risky drinker. Participants allocated to the two intervention groups will receive either a personalised digital intervention or an intervention with enhanced tailoring for motives and readiness to change. The personalised intervention consists of weekly screening, personalised feedback and tools for planning behaviour. The enhanced tailored version will follow the same logic but will contain materials tailored for individuals’ drinking motives and readiness to change. The control group will be redirected to two national websites with information about alcohol and health. Outcome measures are weekly alcohol consumption and monthly heavy drinking episodes, which will be contrasted with regression models and estimated using Bayesian inference.

Ethics and dissemination

Ethical approval was obtained from the Swedish Ethical Review Authority on 16 April 2024, (Dnr 2024-01630-01). The results of the study will be disseminated in academic journals and research conferences.

Trial registration number

The trial was preregistered in the ISRCTN Registry on 12 June 2024 (ISRCTN87600318).

Definition and key concepts of high-performing health systems: a scoping review

Por: Cho · V. · Trowbridge · J. · Perreira · T. · Sodhi · S. · Karsan · A. · Hassan · H. · Perrier · L. · Prokopy · M. · Dale · A. · Brown · A.
Objectives

To determine how high performing is defined in relation to a health system and chart the literature on the definitions and key concepts of high-performing healthcare systems.

Design

Scoping review.

Data sources

MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were searched from inception to July 2024. The grey literature was also searched.

Eligibility criteria

Included studies reported on health systems and high performance to identify explicit definitions, research outcomes and knowledge gaps.

Results

Two reviewers independently screened 5721 citations and 507 full-text articles, resulting in the inclusion of 35 primary articles and 47 companion documents in the review. Three independent definitions for a high-performance health system were identified. 24 research studies reported outcomes on the elements of a high-performing health system (58%), system evaluation (32%) and tool development or validation (10%). Knowledge gaps identified were the lack of a common definition, a lack of common indicators, strategies for moving evidence into policy and practice, and difficulties with comparisons across health systems.

Conclusions

We found limited definitions and a lack of empirical evidence on our topic. There is an opportunity for primary research in the area of health systems and high performance.

❌